Edwards Bar & Grill is a family-run bar and grill.
It has two locations in Scotland: one in South Queensferry (near Edinburgh) and one in Dunfermline.
The South Queensferry branch opened in August 2024. It replaced an older venue on Hopetoun Road.
The Dunfermline spot opened in March 2023.
Owners include Andrew Edwards, his wife Melissa, and nephew Jack. They also hired chefs from well-known kitchens like Down The Hatch and Six By Nico.
Both restaurants have a cozy interior. They feature bar seating, a dining area, and some outdoor space. The Queensferry location adds a beer garden with views of the Forth bridges.
South Queensferry Comparison
| Feature | South Queensferry | Dunfermline |
|---|---|---|
| Open since | Aug 2024 | Mar 2023 |
| Seating capacity | 70 inside, 20 outside. | Not listed |
| Menu variety | Pub classics, seafood, steaks, burgers | British pub classics, steaks, fajitas |
| Live music & events | Yes: music, quizzes, karaoke, sport | Less focus on events |
| Price range | About £25 and under | Mid‑range, similar |
| Booking feedback | Mixed reviews for reservations | Good; consistent ratings |
| Ambience | Great views, vibrant garden | Cozy, friendly, more relaxed |
| Review score (approx.) | 3.9/5 local, 2.7/5 OpenTable | 5/5 (Tripadvisor) |
Location: Edwards South Queensferry
Menu Highlights
Both places serve pub-style food. Here are some shared favorites:
- Haggis bon bons (starter)
- Fish and chips
- Edwards House steak pie
- Burgers (beef, veggie, chicken)
- Sirloin and ribeye steaks
- Fajitas
- Vegetarian and vegan options
- Desserts like sticky toffee pudding, apple pastry, cheesecake.
The Queensferry spot also added a seafood menu and daily chef specials.
Prices
At Queensferry, prices range from £4.50 to £17.50. Mains cost around £9–£15 .
Sunday roast is £17.50.
Deals like 2‑course meals with wine cost about £36–£56 via itison.
Dunfermline prices are similar. They focus on British pub food and do not show steep prices.
Reviews
South Queensferry
Mixed feedback:
- Tripadvisor shows 2.8/5 from 9 reviews. Some diners praise the atmosphere and views.
- Negative reports include slow service and long wait times. A family waited two hours for food on Mother’s Day .
- Booking issues: several users said it was closed during their reservation time .
- Positive feedback mentions friendly staff, good food, and fair value .
- A lovely venue and the service was great
On OpenTable, it has 2.7/5 based on 20 diners . Praise for the beer garden and food quality; criticism for noisy ambiance and booking troubles.
On itison, 3.4/5 rating from 18 reviews. Users liked the home‑cooked feel. They rated 5★ (28%) and 4★ (33%).
Dunfermline
Reviews are strong:
- Tripadvisor gives 5/5 from 4 reviews.
- Reviewers call it a “hidden gem,” praising food quality, service, and local feel.
- RestaurantGuru says staff are creative and service is good.
Pros and Cons
South Queensferry
Pros:
- Lovely beer garden with bridge views.
- Wide food menu, friendly staff.
- Regular live events and entertainment.
Cons:
- Some guests complain about slow service.
- Booking mix-ups and closures at reservation times.
- Ambience can be noisy, especially when music plays
Who It’s For
- South Queensferry is great for visitors. It gives pub food, events, and lovely views.
- Dunfermline suits locals or couples. It focuses on good food and a relaxed vibe.
Tips for Visitors
- Book ahead. Many reviews mention the restaurant being closed or busy.
- Ask for a table in the beer garden if visiting Queensferry on a nice day.
- Check opening times—South Queensferry is closed Mon–Tue.
- Be patient—service can be slow if the kitchen is busy or understaffed.
- Try specials—seafood and steak night deals can offer good value.
Conclusion
Edwards Bar & Grill has real charm. Both places serve big portions of pub classics. Prices are fair. The Queensferry branch has extra perks with views and events. But service is hit or miss. Reservations may fail sometimes.
Dunfermline feels more reliable. It gets strong praise from local customers. It feels cozy and less noisy.
In short:
- Choose Queensferry for atmosphere, live music, and Forth Bridge views.
- Choose Dunfermline for a dependable meal with good service.
Both spots carry the same friendly, family-run energy. I hope this helps you decide where to go. Let me know if you need more info!
FAQs
Q1. Is Edwards South Queensferry a good place to eat?
A: It depends. Some visitors say the food is tasty and fresh. Others had problems with slow service and long waits.
Q2. What kind of food do they serve?
A: They serve pub-style food like burgers, steaks, fish and chips, and Sunday roast. They also have vegetarian options and desserts.
Q3. What do people like most about Edwards Queensferry?
A: Many people like the views of the Forth bridges. The beer garden is popular on sunny days. Some also enjoy the live music and friendly staff.
Q4. Are there any common complaints in reviews?
A: Yes. Some reviews mention long waiting times for food. Others say their booking was cancelled or the place was closed at the time of arrival.
Q5. How are the online ratings?
A: On Tripadvisor, the rating is around 2.8/5. On OpenTable, it’s about 2.7/5. Reviews on Itison are mixed but better, around 3.4/5.
Q6. Is it good for families?
A: Yes. Many families visit. The menu has options for kids and adults. But some reviews mention service delays during busy hours.
Q7. Should I book a table in advance?
A: Yes, especially on weekends. But also check their opening times. Some visitors arrived to find the restaurant unexpectedly closed.
Q8. What is the price range?
A: Most main dishes cost between £9 and £15. Sunday roast is around £17.50. Special meal deals are also available online.
